Fleeing Hitler, France 1940 (Hanna Diamond)

09 +00002013-02-04T18:40:38+00:0028 2012 § 9 Comments

Fleeing Hitler

Although I usually have a crime novel on the go, I read a lot of history and biography as well.  I’ve almost completed Fleeing Hitler: France 1940, by Hanna Diamond (OUP 2007).  This is an extraordinary book about the French flight from Paris after the German invasion of northern France.  Although I’ve read many books about the Second World War, I must say that I hadn’t realised the extent of the exodus that took place.  Parisians were clearly terrified; millions of them abandoned their homes, in most cases taking only the possessions that they could carry or wheel in carts or on bicycles.  A very small minority had cars or vans, but were often forced to abandon these when they ran out of petrol.

Ironically, most of the populace would have been better off staying where they were, unless they were Jewish, as the Germans had no plans to harm them wholesale; in fact, they wanted as many people as possible to carry on working to support the German war effort.  Doubly ironic is that, while Parisians and other inhabitants of northern France and Belgium were panic-stricken and took to the roads with little cause, in Berlin and other urban centres in Germany, German Jews believed that they were safe and stayed until it was too late.  I have no explanation for the extreme fear amongst the French, unless it was caused by the fact that Paris had been invaded four times within living memory, on the last occasion only about a quarter of a century previously.

Of particular fascination is Hanna Diamond’s account of how the quite sophisticated Parisians (though, in many cases, they were only a generation away from having been peasants themselves) reacted to the extremely basic lifestyles of the peasant communities in which they found shelter.  It is a snapshot in time of how two eras, the modern one and the age-old traditional one, collided.  Despite bucolic discomforts, however, a significant number of Parisians did not return to Paris after the panic subsided, but stayed in these rural communities, especially if they could find work.  Some of the wealthier départements were extremely generous; for example, the inhabitants of the Charente gave refugees ten francs each per day, even though they could obtain accommodation and food (‘including drink’!) for about twelve francs per week.  Others – especially those on major routes south, which were assailed by wave after wave of large groups en route – received them with dour suspicion and moved them on as quickly as possible.

I’m not unduly patriotic, but the account in this book of the behaviour of the French government in power at the time of the invasion makes me somewhat proud of the contrasting achievement of the British government of the day.  In Britain, the government gave everyone clear orders about rationing, evacuation of children, building of safety shelters and what to do in case of invasion.  There were also regular news bulletins (though some were censored in order not to demoralise) about what was going on in the rest of Europe.  The French government, by contrast, seemed to be incapable of organising anything at all.  The refugees received no directions besides broad advice on which areas further south they should head for, no financial support, no food, no petrol and no information.  It is hardly surprising that Marshal Pétain and the Vichy government commanded so much support when they first appeared; theirs was the only leadership on offer.

It is estimated that 100,000 people died during the flight from Paris and the subsequent bedraggled return of most of the refugees; many of these victims were children, the old, the ill and the infirm.  Some may actually have starved.  I do wonder, though, how many were murdered.  There were fights for food along the way; fathers and husbands were forced to prostitute daughters and wives in return for petrol and other basics; and returning families sometimes found that their flats had been occupied by German soldiers or by French people who had taken advantage of their absence.  Plenty of scope for nefarious deeds here, I should have thought, including a few undetected murders.

I have found much to interest me in this carefully-researched account of an aspect of the Second World War that does not usually get an airing.  I recommend it.

Tagged: , , , , ,

§ 9 Responses to Fleeing Hitler, France 1940 (Hanna Diamond)

  • carol hedges says:

    My mother was one of the last to leave Hitler’s Germany. She worked for a refugee organisation in Berlin, so stayed almost to the moment Hitler closed the borders. She was on the last train out of Berlin. There is a ffamily story that she was at the back of the queue, and concerned that she wouldn’t get on. The Gestapo came down the line of waiting Jews, checking papers and administering the last bits of humiliation and bullying. They looked at her papers (her organisation was well known ) then beckoned her out of the line. She was sure she was about to be arrested. Instead, they escorted her to the front of the queue, and pushed her through the barrier – clearly she was no longer welcome in her own city. My father’s parents refused to leave Hanover, convinced that people would come to their senses and realise what the Nazis were. ‘The Germans are civilized people. This is the country of Beethoven, Schiller and Heine,’ they said. We never discovered which concentration camp they perished in.

    • Carol, thank you so much for sharing this very personal information. You clearly have a real insight into the lives of ordinary people. Your mother sounds as if she was an extraordinary person and very brave. Of course, your father’s parents were right: the Germans are a civilised people; it was the phenomenon of Nazism which cannot make any sense to rational thinkers and which wrought such terrible crimes. I’m very moved by your comment.

    • vallypee says:

      Christina, it is a testament to Carol’s mother and grandparents, but a very real and chilling piece of history to have in her family,

  • Tom Cunliffe says:

    Just up my street – and I’ve never heard of it before. Very interesting review

  • I have read several books on the same subject, you might like to look at my book list on my blog, there could be others there to interest you….its not a long list!

  • Dear Christina,
    Many thanks for your kind words about my book. You may be interested in visiting my newly launched website:
    Do leave a comment on the site and let us know what you think.
    This came about because so many people wrote to me with their family stories after reading the book. I would be keen if you could encourage people to post their stories there so we can build it up as a valuable resource.
    Would you be interested in writing a guest blog for us?
    With best wishes

    • Hello, Hanna.
      I’m delighted to be able to tell you that this post received a lot of ‘hits’ and I’m really pleased to have been able to share my own enthusiasm for an excellent book which is a clear testament to the research and writing skills of its author. I shall, of course, look at your site; as far as a guest blog is concerned, the answer is ‘yes’.
      I’m very pleased to ‘meet’ you here and sincerely hope that you will return from time to time. 🙂
      With my regards,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

What’s this?

You are currently reading Fleeing Hitler, France 1940 (Hanna Diamond) at Christina James, crime novelist.


%d bloggers like this: